“All I require of my readers […] is that they approach my discussion of Shakespeare’s plays with an open mind and without preconception. […] All that is required of readers is, I would say, what Coleridge calls a ‘willing suspension of disbelief’ “. (Peter Milward, Shakespeare the Papist, 2005)
In the mid-1970s Milward published Shakespeare’s Religious Background, a controversial book in which he worked out the thesis of a Catholic Shakespeare he had been developing for over a decade. In 1985 Honigmann acknowledged that Milward was the first “to recognize how all the ‘Lancashire’ clues in Shakespeare’s biography support one another” (Honigmann, Shakespeare: The ‘Lost’ Years).